"This Book Is Just a Big Lie"
Scene: Sunday at the Barnes & Noble. I am reading to the Raggirls a book that I think all three of them will enjoy.
Me: "George was a very curious monkey, but he always seemed to be getting into trouble . . ."
Eldest Raggirl: He doesn't have a tail.
Medium Raggirl: Yeah, he doesn't have a tail!
Me: What?
ER: He doesn't have a tail.
Me: He doesn't have a tail. So?
MR: Monkeys have tails. If it doesn't have a tail, its not a monkey.
ER: Yeah. I learned that in school. If he doesn't have a tail, George is an ape, not a monkey.
Me: So, Curious George is an ape?
ER: Yes, but it says that he was a curious "monkey." This book is just a big lie.
Disillusioned by literature, Eldest and Medium Raggirl wandered away. Youngest Raggirl, being less than 2 years old, was less concerned about the Ape/ Monkey distinction, and continued to enjoy the story.
Me: "George was a very curious monkey, but he always seemed to be getting into trouble . . ."
Eldest Raggirl: He doesn't have a tail.
Medium Raggirl: Yeah, he doesn't have a tail!
Me: What?
ER: He doesn't have a tail.
Me: He doesn't have a tail. So?
MR: Monkeys have tails. If it doesn't have a tail, its not a monkey.
ER: Yeah. I learned that in school. If he doesn't have a tail, George is an ape, not a monkey.
Me: So, Curious George is an ape?
ER: Yes, but it says that he was a curious "monkey." This book is just a big lie.
Disillusioned by literature, Eldest and Medium Raggirl wandered away. Youngest Raggirl, being less than 2 years old, was less concerned about the Ape/ Monkey distinction, and continued to enjoy the story.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home